.
Feedback

Petition Seeks Life For Accused Killers of Barabara Latiolais

Internet petition circulated by her stepson's family seeks for tough sentences for accused Castro Valley teens Christian Birdsall and Cody Nicosia.

 

Ryan Rice wants to make sure the punishment fits the crime.

As the stepson of Barbara Latiolais, the Castro Valley woman who was strangled and burned to death in October, that means life in prison without the possibility of parole.

With the help of his girlfriend, Amanda Miller, Rice is circulating an Internet petition asking for support in making sure that the accused -- 16-year-old Christian Birdsall and 18-year-old Cody Nicosia -- never leave jail.

"I'm 200 percent convinced they're guilty," Rice, 24, said in a telephone interview from Texas where he lives with Miller, 22, and their two-year-old son.

Rice grew up in Castro Valley and was raised by Barbara Latiolais as if he were her son. Ryan Rice said he is moving back to Castro Valley soon to be close to his dad, Mike Rice -- who was the longtime partner of Latiolais.

The petition is toughly worded: "These monsters knew exactly what they were doing, and should recieve no mercy."

You can read it here

Castro Valley has been shocked and divided by the killings. Many people knew the accused and/or the victim. There have been heated exchanges in the comments.

Mike Rice, who is the father of Ryan and the former partner of Barbara Latiolais, shared his grief over her killing in a Patch interview.

Mike Rice has set up “The Barbara Latiolais Memorial Fund” to help her daughter, Lalanya Felix, 40, who lives in Tracy, and his son, Ryan, cope with the fallout.

Inteested parties can make donations in person or by mail at any Wells Fargo branch.

Write “Barbara Latiolais Memorial Fund” and account number 1392401558 on the check. Online contributions are also possible but the process will vary from bank to bank.  If needed, Wells Fargo’s ABA routing number is 121042882.

 

 

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Castro Valley Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Mike December 26, 2012 at 03:14 pm
They'll die of old age in a comfy segregated cell before we ever execute them in this state, so putting them in general population devoid of sunlight for the rest of their horrible, undeserved lives is the next best thing.
Rai W. December 26, 2012 at 10:02 pm
Though I share empathy with the family and justice should be served, I will not support a life sentance without parole for the 16 yr old petition. His life is permantly ruined regardless if he serves his life or not and our judicial system is entirely broken to the point that we are treating more and more youth crimes as adult trials. Most 16 year olds DO NOT know what they are doing and this is a bad crime that turned terrible. I wish you luck in reaching your goal.
patty December 26, 2012 at 11:53 pm
Rai: Are you serious??? This kid knew ezactly what he was doing. This 16 year old was not an innocent bystander. They killed my aunt and didn't think twice. For your sake,I hope you never have to feel the pain we do.
Marga Lacabe December 27, 2012 at 01:11 am
Rai, thank you for having the courage to speak against life sentences for minors.
The United States is the only country in the world where children are given such sentences. As a society, we seem to think that the response to cruelty should be more cruelty, to death, should be more death. But of course, the crueler we are as a people, the less understanding and compassion we have for others, the less they will have for us - and for the dissolving social contract. Patty, I know you are hurting and I have no answers as to why these kids did what they did. But the brain of a teenager does not work like the brain of an adult, study after study shows that. And the law recognizes that. The law won't allow children under 18 to vote, buy lottery tickets, drink or smoke, get tattoos, join the military, get plastic surgery, get married without parental consent, or even have sex! We don't think they have the judgment to make such decisions for themselves - so how can we possibly believe they have the same judgment as an adult when it comes to killing a person?
patty December 27, 2012 at 03:33 pm
Unfortunately neither Rai or Marga have any idea what the family and friends are feeling. These kids made a decision to go rob a house and leave no witnesses behind. It is a sad day when anybody believes someone at 16 years old has no idea what they are doing. In these studies, how do you think they got their responses? They asked questions and the answers they got led them to believe 16 year olds do not think like adults. By the way, murder is not an adult decision either, it is a dumb decision and a life changing one. Kids are not stupid, they know how to answer to manipulate people. My aunt trusted this kid, cause she knew him or thought she did. It is a sad day when murder is expected to be slipped under the rug and let the murderers get away with it. I hope they get everything they deserve and I will pray for their souls because that is where they are really going to need help. I just hope for your sake you never go through something like this. These kids need to be off the streets for the rest of their lives.
Marga Lacabe December 27, 2012 at 04:26 pm
Patty, I know you are hurting. I can't imagine how much. But, as a society, we've progressed beyond doling punishment based on the hurt of the victim's families.
And neither Rai nor I are arguing that the kids should be let free. What they did was horrendous, incomprehensible, and these kids are very dangerous. They need to be somewhere where they cannot hurt others. But they are teens. Ten, twenty years from now, forty years from now, they may be very different people. I believe very strongly that for most people, in particular for young kids, change is possible. And indeed, that's what neuroscience suggests. The studies are not based on questionnaires, but basically on observations of teen and adult brains and neural activity in response to different stimuli. But Patti, I don't mean to convince you, you have the right to your grief, to your anger, to your desire for justice/revenge. At some point you will want to understand, and information about the adolescent brain will be useful, but that has to be done at your own pace. I really wish you the best.
Jessica Gardner December 27, 2012 at 04:42 pm
Didn't the Supreme Court just rule on this? You cannot give them the death penalty for a crime committed while under 18
Jessica Gardner December 27, 2012 at 04:46 pm
And life in prison?
Marga Lacabe December 27, 2012 at 04:59 pm
The US Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life sentences for minors were unconstitutional, but they can be imposed by a judge that looks at the circumstances of each crime/defendant.
In California, there is a new law that says that allows judges to reconsider the sentence of minors convicted to life in prison without parole after 15 years in prison. The judge would then be able to reduce the sentence to 25 years.
Marga Lacabe December 27, 2012 at 05:00 pm
Your are right.
patty December 27, 2012 at 10:37 pm
As I said, I hope you never feel what we feel. I never spoke of revenge. I don't believe in revenge. God is the only judge I care to listen to. But God is perfect justice and He will do what he sees fit. If these kids don't spend the rest of their life in prison, I hope they don't prove those out there that feel sorry for them, wrong. My aunt did not deserve to die like that. Her children did not deserve to lose their mother and her grandchildren will now grow up without her. That is the reality. They not only killed her but they killed a piece in many people who loved her dearly.
Jessica Gardner December 28, 2012 at 02:31 am
Patty,
Many obviously don't know or feel your families pain and it must be devastating and am sorry your family is going through this. I am only commenting because the article states the family is asking people for donations and the cause is to put a 16 year old to be sentenced to life in prison with no parole. The Supreme Court has recently ruled on this and as much as you may want this sentence it's prob not reality. Both of these boys if found guilty will be sent away for a very long time and perhaps never get out.
Bruce Browne December 28, 2012 at 07:49 pm
Give me a break. These "kids" committed a pre-meditated murder. Then they went out and had lunch with the money they stole from this innocent woman. Then they drove around the East Bay in her car and partied it up. Then while in the process of all this celebrating, they came to their senses and realized that they left incriminating evidence behind at the crime scene, so they went back and set the whole house on fire!
I am certain that these young men will have an epiphany while spending time in prison, but that is no reason to let them out before they die of old age. Many people throughout the Bay Area have commented that this crime was one of the most awful murders they have ever heard of, but they have also said something else. There have been many who have noted how outrageous it is that so many people have made such a heartfelt effort to defend the two killers, make excuses for them, and plead for judicial forgiveness. This is not only absurd, it is an insult to the victim's family and friends. I would like to say to all the people who loved and cared for Barbara Latiolais that the majority of the general public is on your side. I am truly sorry that any of you have had to endure these outrageous comments by a small minority of insensitive "do gooders" who would not feel the same way if this had happened to their loved one. These two young men deserve a life term with no parole period. Let them spend the rest of their lives thinking about their crime.
patty December 28, 2012 at 10:05 pm
Thank you Bruce. Well said!!!
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Boulevard Burger CV June 14, 2013 at 11:34 pm
There was an attempted robbery, someone, possibly the suspect was shot on Castro Valley Boulevard.Read More None of our employees were involved in the shooting.
Kari Hulac (Editor) June 15, 2013 at 07:34 am
Thanks for letting us know BVCV. Sorry to hear this happened at your business.
The Goonies
Randy Waage June 13, 2013 at 10:43 am
Great fun, classic movie and theater! Glad we still have such an amazing & beautiful theater inRead More San Leandro!
MICHELLE CLOWSER June 9, 2013 at 10:11 pm
If CV is great, and I am not disputing that fact, why would you want to change it's nature?Read More Wouldn't that change the very things that you are trying to protect and preserve?
Ken Martin June 11, 2013 at 12:50 pm
You can't compare Castro Valley with Menlo Park. Menlo Park is on the edge of Silicon Valley and hasRead More much more income per capita than Castro Valley could ever hope to have. Certainly the county is a lousy and unfair administrator, but we can at least afford them (somewhat). It is extremely unlikely that we could support a city unless you lie a lot about our finances like the incorporation proponents did during the last election.
Sarah Hyre DC June 12, 2013 at 10:48 am
Thank you for sharing this. I am moved by your courage to be honest with yourself about what youRead More want for your daughter and your willingness to give her up so she can have what she needs in this life. Also giving parents and opportunity to be parents who can't have kids of their own. This touches my heart. <3